JonHoyle.com Mirror of MacCompanion
http://www.maccompanion.com/macc/archives/December2008/Software/NED3.htm

macCompanion MyAppleSpace Forum Archives Products Services About Us FAQs

Resources

                                           

Consultants

Developers

Devotees

Downloads

"Foreign" Macs

Forums

Hearsay

Link Lists

Mac 3D

Macazines

Mac Jobs

MUG Shots

News

Radio

Reviews

Think Different

Training

 

Nonlinear Educating Device (N.E.D.) 3.0.1 Software Tutorial-Video Player

Reviewed by Robert Pritchett

macProVideo.com

PO Box 93598

Vancouver, BC

V6E 4L7

(604) 628-7981

Contact Form

Released: Version 1 of N.E. D. April 23, 2007. Version 3.0.1 November 13, 2008.

Demos

Requirements: Mac OS X 10.5 or later, QuickTime 7 or later. G4 or later.
A healthy Internet connection is recommended, but it will work with 56K Modems.


Tutorials range from free up to $50 USD.


Strengths: This training app manages your tutorial downloads, which allows you to begin watching your training almost immediately (videos download incrementally in the background).


Weaknesses: Previous versions had less intuitive download controls; N.E.D. 3 seems to meet the "third time's a charm" rule!

 

Forum

Reviewed with Mac OS X 10.5l5 and MacBook Pro 17".

 

Introduction

 

macProVideo has released N.E.D. 3, which allows for  downloading and running tutorials within the N.E.D. structure on the Mac. Many of these are for professional packages from Apple and many others, which are masterpieces on the Mac but not made by Apple. This is the list of trainers - http://www.macprovideo.com/trainer/all

 

Videos can begin immediately after download. The Photoshop CS4 101 tutorial had 42 sections, but I could begin without having to download all of them before starting training. The other lessons downloaded  behind the scenes.

 

Apparently, if you have a Mac with a Remote, it also works with N.E.D.3.  If you feel a need to save to CD or DVD, you may from inside the app as well. 

 

Videos can be resized on the fly without degradation and run at 1024x768.

 


What I Learned

 

The few tutorials I've downloaded have been first rate, quality by excellent presenters. These are designed to get you up-and-running in record time. Because there are both an N.E.D update and a purchased Tutorial Update function, it would appear that these paid-for tutorials will stay current with their targeted apps as long as the apps are supported by their developers. This sets macProVideo apart from the competition in the tutorial market.

 

I like the way the flow-as-you-go works with the segment-to-segment education process. The segments are short enough to get the idea across so I can stop, go try it and come back to continue on to the next concept.

 

Previous versions of N.E.D. had issues for the Mac. This one seems to have overcome those. While doing this review, the 3.0.1 update arrived. The new dock icon as shown above seems to be a bone of contention for some users. It doesn’t bother me.

 

I got this message back from Gosia Zobel, regarding where the tutorials are located, since I was initially unable to locate them;

 

"NED 3 saw a massive overhaul to the entire download management system. Previous versions use a web-based download manager that some users found to be less intuitive than if it were program-based; as such we implemented built-in download management controls. Additionally, we overhauled the general look and layout of the player controls, and gave 'N.E.D.' a more human feel, with our new icon."

 

"The tutorials aren't hidden, the are stored in Documents > NED as .prgm files."

 

Now that I can see the size of the files, I would suggest that you be connected to a broadband Internet connection, because you probably will not like a 56K modem to take a few hours to do a download. Both the Flash CS4 101 and Photoshop CS4 101 tutorials are 914.4 MB and 892.2 MB respectively.

 

Conclusion

 

N.E.D. 3 is an excellent way to keep up-to-speed on training and education regarding Mac-based professional apps. And the pricing structure is much better than that found with the competition.  Having a path available for updates and access to literally thousands of lesson makes this a viable option for enterprise-level training.